Jun 18, 2014

MOCKING MOOCS



On June 16, 2014, a governmental appointed expert group released an Official Norwegian Report on MOOCs in higher education (NOU 2014: 5. MOOC til Norge. Nye digitale læringsformer i høyere utdanning). The group states that the report is «hairy» - others will probably look at it as a hair in the soup. The report suggests governmental measures that require NOK 130-380 (Euro 16-48) million in yearly investments. This initiates a welcome debate about all the good online education initiatives during the last decades – and how we can improve future online education.

Just before the report was released, I took part in the development of the Kragerø Open Online Education Declaration together with a group of 14 Nordic experts associated with NooA – the Nordic open online Academy. Our discussions revealed that online learning and education covers a much broader range of activities, issues and opportunities than MOOCs. Therefore, the issues and statements that were discussed during the workshop, then refined and prioritised through an online Delphi process, resulted in the following declaration and 23 statements supporting it:

“We strongly believe that the current open education values and practice will improve, innovate and even revolutionize learning and education worldwide. In many cases, it can be more flexible, economical and open than traditional education. Online learning and education can potentially emulate all educational activities in schools and colleges, not only single courses as the MOOCs do. We urge politicians, bureaucrats, managers, researchers, course designers, teachers and students to develop, promote and support quality online learning and education”.

Norway needs sustainable online education. We should avoid the mistakes the Swedish authorities made with Nätuniversitetet. During three years, they injected several hundred million kroner in colleges and universities that developed online courses. This resulted in many excellent online courses – which were discontinued – when the extraordinary funding from Nätuniversitetet ended. Such initiatives are also problematic since they can make it difficult for sound, but unfunded, initiatives to survive because of the temporarily unfair competition.

It can also be useful to learn from the EU-project: Megatrends in E-learning Provision. In the book Online Education – Global e-learning in a Scandinavian perspective, I present the project’s analyses of 26 large, successful online education initiatives. Maybe we can learn even more from the ten large initiatives that not were successful. MOOC-advocates should read the project recommendations – especially the first of the seven related to the failed initiatives: Many governmental online education initiatives have not been sustainable

MOOCs are prized for being free and open for everyone. At the same time, they are criticised for disturbingly high dropout rates, insufficient student support and lacking business models. It reminds me of the arguments that were used in the heyday of public educational broadcasting.

Both educational broadcasting and MOOCs need sustainable financial models to succeed. It is therefore thought-provoking that colleges and universities start to provide free online services when newspapers reverse this strategy. MOOC-providers struggle to find sustainable business models. They test the opportunities to charge for access to teachers, technical support, student support services, exams, certificates and additional content. These services are often lacking or insufficient in MOOCs, but for decades, they have been obvious services included in traditional online education.

As the CEO of Campus NooA, I see that we need online courses for small- and medium sized businesses and organizations, courses with flexible start-up and progression and online education providers that handle a broader range of services that online students, teachers and staff need. I therefore have the following three questions related to the MOOC-advocates:

1. Small- and medium sized business and organizations have countless training and learning needs that are well suited for online courses, but not for MOOCs. One example is the course Spanish for adopting parents, which Campus NooA developed in collaboration with Adopsjonsforum for about 50 adopting parents in Norway. Even for such small groups of people, online courses can be flexible, cost effective and good. So, why don’t we focus more on flexible online courses for smaller and closed groups?

2. Today, people often have busy lives with job- and family responsibilities that require flexible start-up and progression plans. Campus NooA and some other providers specialise in this. So, I wonder if the MOOCs represent a setback regarding this flexibility?

3. Why should universities and colleges provide open online courses to everyone? Shouldn’t they focus on providing a wide range of good online services to their own students? And not only individual MOOC courses, but complete Bachelor, Master and Doctoral programmes?

Finally, it is thought-provoking that online education has not developed as swiftly as I thought when I wrote my 1989 article: in Search of a Virtual School.

10 comments:

  1. Which Undergrad Major is Most Preferred by the Top MBA Programs?
    Asvab Practice Math Question

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting blog and I really like your work and must appreciate you work for the forward my address good work.
    Dissertation Help

    ReplyDelete
  3. you are providing great and quality services, i appreciate you. Thanks for sharing as it is an excellent post would love to read your future post.
    Dissertation Help

    ReplyDelete
  4. An interesting report on higher education department of Norway. I read this post very keenly and found that their education system is some different from ours. So if any student has any confusion about the education system so he should visit Buy Dissertation Online for any assistance.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This blog is very informative and useful for me, You are providing great information!

    Zoho Implementation

    ReplyDelete
  6. "We are the best share market course provider to you and you will always get the best deal out of it. you must be planning for the share market course institute in jaipur and we are the one who will always provided you the right path and you will get the best quality and this will get the straight amount and that you can be the best way to secure you profit in the market and this will keep on guiding you the best and the best share market course they will get the right choice of share market course and this will get the best out of the training and you will ,
    we are the best share market course institute in the market, we provide the best knowledge of the share market course. You will always get the best faculty to study with, they will always make you the expert in the share market course. NIWS (National Institute of Wall Street) we are Jaipur-based institute and we have the branch over other cities also like Delhi. You can contact us through google also it will always be beneficial for you to work with us. we will always try to make you grab the knowledge. “NIWS” National Institute of Wall Street, is one of the top institutes in its domain with a wide list of courses, ranging from Banking, Finance, share Market, Portfolio and Wealth Management to Technical and Fundamental analysis. With over 10-15 years of experience as professionals in domestic and international markets, we strive to help students to achieve their lifelong career goals and aspirations. for more visit NIWS share market course institute in Jaipur is one of the best institutes in the market, a student in generally go to find the share market institute and they get it in the false promises from the institutes but if you come to the NIWS here you will get the best counseling from the faculty and they will always train you the best in the share market, this. all make the NIWS the best Share market course institute in the state”” NIWS”
    We are the best stock market institute in Delhi , if you want to learn the stock market course in Delhi then you should contact us with the best share market institute in Delhi , we provided the best stock market course in Delhi for you people and that will get you the best thing of this your life career and that will take you to the right choice and the things that you will get to you is the best thing around and you can get the best thing in the stock market course in Delhi , if you are planning the best stock market institute in Delhi . if you are planning the best stock market course in Delhi we are the best stock market course institute in Delhi, we provide the best knowledge of the stock market market course. You will always get the best faculty to study with, they will always make you the expert of the Stock market course in Delhi. NIWS (National Institute of Wall Street) we are Jaipur based institute and we have the branch over other cities also like Delhi. You can contact us through google also it will always be beneficial for you to work with us. we will always try to make you grab the knowledge. “NIWS” National Institute of Wall Street, is one of the top institutes in its domain with a wide list of courses, ranging from Banking, Finance, Stock Market, Portfolio and Wealth Management to Technical and Fundamental analysis. With over 10-15 years experienced professionals in domestic and international markets, we strive to help students to achieve their lifelong career goals and aspirations. for more visit NIWS
    NIWS is one of the best share market institute in India, a student in generally go to find the best share market institute in India and they get it in the false promises from the institutes but if you come to the NIWS here you will get the best counseling from the faculty and they will always train you the best in the stock market, this all make the NIWS the best stock market course institute in Delhi."

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This blog is beneficial for me, thank you for this amazing information!

    We are providing the best zoho books accounting software in Pakistan, UAE, KSA, and Bahrain.

    Zoho Books

    ReplyDelete
  9. Want to become an expert in trading? Then, take Share Market Courses from IBBM. It is the best institute to learn about share market. Our easy to understand courses will make you an expert on share market. Our teachers provide in-depth knowledge and practical insights about market. Start your trading journey now!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Jamadhan is the Top Share Market Institute in Jaipur. Their courses cover everything you need to know about the stock market, from the basics to advanced topics

    ReplyDelete